.
Feedback

Was HBO's "Game Change" a Political Game Changer?

We found Julianne Moore's portrayal of Sarah Palin remarkable... and chilling.

 

Patch was weaned on political thrillers. From Broderick Crawford in All The King's Men (1949), to the eerily creepy Angela Lansbury in Manchurian Candidate (1962), to Redford and Hoffman's depiction of Woodward and Bernstein in All The President's Men (1976), deftly handled stories on the back-stories and intrigues of American politics kept us in our seat.

And Saturday it was Game Change -- HBO's attempt to capture Sarah Palin's 2008 bid for the vice presidency.

Move aside, Angela.

We're not into movie stars or actors even though we know it's hard to step inside someones skin and portray them as vividly as Julianne Moore, Ed Harris, and Woody Harrelson did for Palin, John McCain and McCain campaign puppet master Steve Schmidt in Game Change.

Frankly, we are rooted in real-world politics and have a hard time allowing ourselves to be "transported" to any make-believe land, though at times Sunday we thought Julianne Moore was Sarah Palin.

The performances, pacing, and story-telling were grand, and we found ourselves smiling when suspicions we'd held about the real-life Palin campaign were borne out in the movie.

Still, Game Change was not an ESPN documentary, seen through the unblinking eye of a hand-held camera, and we couldn't help but wonder how close a view of reality HBO was giving us. Even though many of Schmidt's team apparently contributed to the dialogue and we certainly remembered the "I can see Russia from my house" faux pax and other moments in Palin History that Game Change depicts, how close to the GOP's 2008 run did it come?

The McCain/Palin camps are not happy with the effort, a reaction you could see coming even if you did live on the other side of the Bering Sea, but for the most part the film appears to be getting rave reviews.

For us, it was all about the momentum Palin provided a political campaign during its bid for the highest office in our land, an effort that included plucking an untested, straight-talking mother of five from the wilds of Wasilla, turning her into a prime-time political player, and then standing back in shock and horror as her lack of knowledge about the world outside of her small town in Alaska brought her down like a shotgunned Mallard.

Also of interest to us at least was why Palin was picked to run with McCain in the first place, with Game Change leading us to believe that it was simpy because  she was a woman, conservative, attractive and from Alaska.

How about you, PatchPoliticos? We know from past comments you're keenly interested in politics local and national. Did any of you catch Game Change? Think it was fair? Meant to entertain only? A hit piece?

Zoe Claire March 12, 2012 at 03:48 pm
I thought they were kind to her.
lisa b March 12, 2012 at 11:40 pm
The only movie/documentary worth seeing is The Undefeated, about Sarah Palin's life. It showed how the left-wing media bias is compiled of disgusting people who bullied and slandered her and her family. A fabulous, strong woman who has integrity and morals. If the media and Hollywood made you hate her, watch 'The Undefeated' and you will be completely ashamed of yourself, that is, if you actually have a soul.
Eileen March 13, 2012 at 12:51 am
It's only been 4-5 years since the 2008 prez campaign, but it felt so much longer when I watched "Game Change." Most striking was the memory of how angry I was, as a Hillary supporter, of the media's infatuation with Obama and mistreatment of her, and how excited I was when Palin took the floor at the GOP convention and delivered a great speech. She wowed me and I was open to voting for McCain/Palin. I had forgotten that.
Of course, as the 2008 campaign wore on, it became clear how ill-prepared she was for the job of being a 70-something's hearbeat away from the presidency, and I gave my support to Obama/Biden. Whether or not you are a fan of Palin's what I think the movie highlighted - and is crystal clear from her actions over the last four years - is that she never understood that she needed to (1) "study up" on domestic policies and international affairs if she wanted to be taken seriously, politically, and (2) ingratiate herself with the GOP leadership, to realize her ambition for higher levels of service, on the national stage. I want to see more women in positions of political power, on both sides of the aisle. Unfortunately, due to a lack of intellectual curiosity and/or an unwillingness to put in the time, women like Sarah Palin haven't moved the cause forward. Honestly, I wish it were otherwise.
Trissy March 13, 2012 at 01:10 am
My favorite part of the movie was at the beginning, where the house fell on Sarah's sister.
Michael Taylor March 13, 2012 at 01:17 am
Even though I hate the fact that we have gotten to the point where we are willing to select our leaders based on what they wear and how many homespun tales they can recite, I ended up feeling sorry for Palin as depicted in this movie. I mean, that's a lot of pressure to be under and who wouldn't miss their family etc. But chilling, yeh, in that at the end they have her liking it, and wanting more, even though she had no more grip on foreign affairs than my cat Harry. Entertaining and it asked some good questions but I don't take it as truth.
Lee daniels March 13, 2012 at 01:27 am
While I agree that mortal people often do not do very well in the glare of media attention that comes with a bid for public office and that that glare is often unfair I also have to say I want a vice president who doesn't have to write crib notes on her arm during public appearances.
Deborah March 13, 2012 at 10:42 am
Consider the source...always. History is written by the victors and always contains lies of omission - a manipulation technique. The new opinion piece by Duffy Carolan ( http://lamorinda.patch.com/articles/guest-editorial-dragging-government-into-the-cold-harsh-light-of-day ) cites how governments are circling the wagons and impeding the process of getting information. They're using the manipulation techniques of delay, defer, silence, and truth twisting, banking on reporters' exhaustion and inability to continue to pursue information.
It's a miracle we get any truth these days. One way to get truth - always get both sides of the story. Even then, it's difficult, if one side is telling the truth, while the other side is lying, creating an uneven playing field. However, without both sides, it's impossible to get to the truth, which makes it impossible to change things for the better going forward, for all solutions are based on truth and transparency. Problem: It takes more time and effort to flesh out the truth. Our culture is less and less willing to devote that time, unfortunately.
Lafayette Raised March 13, 2012 at 12:26 pm
The Director and Writer of the movie spoke with 25 GOP staffers who worked on the campaign, conducting over two dozen interviews. In order to discover an accurate version of the "truth" they did what they were supposed to do, spoke with people who were actually there. That, and the fact that many of the campaign events are contained in interviews, articles, speeches and debates which are archived.
amyrene March 13, 2012 at 02:10 pm
We watched "The Undefeated" last night. I find it interesting that a person who went up against "Big Oil" and stood her ground, who brought in growth to her town as mayor and took on the old guard Republicans is not what we are looking for is beyond me. She brought in reform that had politicans there being arrested do to their ethics with their backroom deals. Maybe this is why both the dem and old regime rep have tried to destory her...she means what she says and would do much to make those changes...this concerns those who have their hands in the cookie jar now. I find the attempt of complete destruction of Mrs. Palin and her family sickening. Not many people could of withstood what she has been put through which leads me to believe more in her convictions and those for her are real and when did that become a bad thing. I don't know why people are surprised at the HBO movie it is nothing different than the other garbage they usually air. We stopped paying extra for all the useless movie channes years ago.
Nancy Lee March 13, 2012 at 03:10 pm
In this day and age of talking heads and tailored suits and pressed blue jeans all I ask of my elected officials is that they have a better than working knowledge of world affairs --- and know that Germany was involved in WWI and II, and perhaps be able to tell me where it is.
Orinda mom March 13, 2012 at 04:40 pm
Maybe you can ask Nicolle Devenish Wallace, who grew up in Orinda and went to Miramonte and Cal. She went on to write a novel that is about a vice presidential candidate. I think maybe I'll read it--I bet she put a lot of things into it that actually happened with Palin.
Chris Nicholson March 13, 2012 at 10:10 pm
I think the book was much more balanced in its portrayal. The HBO movie exaggerated both Palin's goodness in the first half and her weaknesses in the second half. I don't think Palin was/is/will ever be qualified to be VP, let alone POTUS, but it was still a biased hit piece.
Robin Goodman March 13, 2012 at 11:52 pm
I'll take a big breath and say now that we're going to have President Obama around for another four years, and that we're lucky to have him. I'm sure if you got Sarah Palin alone for cocktails she would be charming and fun to talk with but I don't want her as my vice president and I certainly don't see her as president.
X March 14, 2012 at 02:04 am
Robin...Cocktails? Surely, you'd want to have breakfast with her.
Let's see....I'll do my best here...It's late and I'm running this off the top of my head so don't get your hopes too high....... Well, Ms. Palin's definitely as pretty as a model, but you may find that she's a thumping bore. Or worse. She might just march you over to the zoo and feed you to the yak. From time to time, she gives me the mean reds. The mean reds are horrible. Suddenly you're afraid and you don't know what you're afraid of. ...Robin...Hopefully, this effort wasn't too shameful. Sometimes, I can miss the mark. But, in my defense, I do always give women the most fabulous earrings possible and I think that tells them everything they need to know. Wouldn't you agree?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Lamorinda Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Contra Costa Veterinary Hospital June 7, 2013 at 09:06 am
Woohoo!!! Congratulations to all the adopted pets, families with new pets and the rescues for comingRead More together for such a great cause :)
Laura June 7, 2013 at 10:49 am
Fantastic. I watched a gorgeous orange tabby get selected by a couple when I was buying cat food.Read More Made my day. Way to go CC4C and Pet Food Express.
greg w June 6, 2013 at 04:01 pm
Two of them - one high, one low...guessing burglars or mountain lion
eruc June 6, 2013 at 05:32 pm
KCBS reports missing 23 year old missing man. Vague report but citizens are asked to call police ifRead More seen.
eruc June 6, 2013 at 05:35 pm
More about this...Read More http://www.mercurynews.com/top-stories/ci_23406312/lafayette-police-searching-missing-at-risk-adult