.
Feedback

Newspaper Wars -- Or Just Harpooning the Competition?

Recent discovery of news racks from a competing publication in the garbage bins of the San Jose Mercury News prompts an eyebrow raise and memories of old-fashioned newspaper wars of yore.

 

Back in the day when seven or eight newspapers competed for readership in big cities across the land tales of creative backstabbing and derring-do by everyone from reporters to bundle spotters were commonplace.

In San Francisco, where your editor sharpened his pen and carried a notepad for far, far too many years, the stories of day-to-day competition between giants like Hearst and Theriot were legion -- and legendary. In the Front Page days of the 20s, 30s, and 40s it was dog-eat dog, kill or be killed, get the story before the competition or be kicked to the curb.

And in Depression-era America, getting kicked to the curb could be a death sentence, so "The Boys" and few gals who made up the Fourth Estate back then got creative in their efforts to make sure they came out ahead while the other guy or gal and their paper didn't come out at all.

This journalistic monkey wrenching took many forms, I was told by the paunchy, world-weary and deeply jaded word warriors who brought me into "the business." One was fond of hanging a neatly-lettered "Out of Order" sign on the nearest available courtroom payphone, lazily trailing behind as his speedier, younger colleague from the Chronicle puffed up to the perfectly good instrument with the latest word on a "guilty" verdict only to spy the sign and wheeze away in search of a "functioning" blower -- and leaving the Examiner man to remove his sign and phone his desk at leisure.

There were other tricks of the trade, up to and including jacking up the rear axle of a competitor's city car and phoning in a dummy jail escape story to watch the ensuing calamity of a newsman with an exclusive in his jaws try to figure out why his tachometer was revving into the stratosphere but his car was not going anywhere. Another old trick, used by the bundle spotters and delivery drivers  crisscrossing the city with stacks of papers in the wee small hours, was to leave stacks of extra papers on a street corner while scooping up the competition's news racks -- papers and all -- and throwing them into their truck when no one was looking.

That the racks were jettisoned from the end of Pier 32 into the Bay (ecology hadn't been invented, yet) held little interest for the boys or their hijinks, unless of course their racks were being hijacked and it was their papers that ended up sleeping with the fishes. Turnabout is fair play, after all.

It was interesting then, to see this week that the owners of at least one local publication were screaming "foul" after several of their newsracks turned up and were photographed in the dumpster of a larger competitor -- who allegedly tried to peddle the story that the police had instructed them to "clean up" non-compliant news racks that happened to be on their corners.

Hmm. While "The Baron," "Scoop" Glover, and the "Silver Fox" may have smiled wistful smiles behind their Thin Man mustaches, shrugged, and explained the move away with a "that's the way the cookie crumbles," this kind of thing does not play as well as it did back in the 20s.

Lawyers are being unholstered and accusations of First Amendment violations are being tossed around. The whole escapade has reminded your editor of the political haboob which boiled up and consumed then-Police Chief Richard Hongisto after he ordered his men to gather up the racks of a gay newspaper running an unflattering caricature and story about him in 1992.

That kind of thing just isn't done in San Francisco, ahem, no sir -- and Hongisto ended his brief term as chief soon afterward. I guess those dog-eat-dog times are back, only with consequences for those who get caught.

It sounded like things were more fun back in the Old Days -- at least, if you believe those press room stories, that is.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Lamorinda Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Napoleon Solo May 21, 2013 at 10:55 am
I agree with all of that. I consider myself rather recent to either of those sites so I'll defer toRead More your knowledge of it. My issue with Patch was how they seem to try to create tension and arguments, and especially if they get a good fight going, seem to bring in groups that clearly are not local. I have little interest in debating issues with someone from Fremont, for example. I agree that News is doing a great job of local coverage. I can infer from some of the bits of information that one of their writers lives within a few blocks of me.
Chris Nicholson May 21, 2013 at 10:42 am
NapSol: News24-680 has its flaws, but I haven't heard other complaints about censorship. It's aRead More crew of people who were doing "hyper local" reporting BEFORE Patch came to town and they seem to be poised to outlive Patch. We'll see. Even before the big reductions in editorial/reporting resources per Patch site, News 24-680 seemed to do a better job covering core local stories-- albeit with less overall content/audience than here. Some of the regional/generic Patch stories are, IMHO, fine. But if Patch loses even more of its local flavor I suspect interest/traffic will wane.
Napoleon Solo May 21, 2013 at 09:53 am
I'm not sure what it means to "move to" the news24-680 site. Converation there does notRead More seem to be encouraged beyond shallow "me too" kind of comments. If there are any conversations of any substance there, I have yet to find them. I know some or many of the discussions here were disfunctional, but at least there were conversations. I did a test posting there yesterday and it was censored or at least never showed up. My post was in response to an interview of a St. Mary's economist who is against trying to lower the $1 trillion dollar federal deficit spending. I did not say anything disrespectful as I recall, but I guess it was censored cause it contained actual ideas. By the way, I used to be an economist on one of the largest trading floors in the world, so in my opinion, its OK for me to have a different view. The News people I guess don't think so. Will still look at it cause it has some nice local news but its not for participating.
Chris Nicholson May 19, 2013 at 09:38 am
LamoMan: "Back to school" is beginning of year and "Open House" is toward theRead More end. W/R/T high school, I agree with you that it's not as fun as K-5. I was disappointed, for example, to see no exemplary integral homework stapled to the wall of Calculus class-- I love the funny f/s hybrid symbol. Basically, I was bullied into attending by my wife (and the lure of Taco Truck catering). In seriousness, it was nice to stop by and (re)connect names and faces and be reminded of the dedication and talent of many (but not, ahem, all) of the teachers we're lucky enough to have here.
LamorindaMan May 18, 2013 at 11:46 pm
I don't have children so maybe I'm missing something. But, what is the point of an open house at theRead More high school level and what is the point of an open house at the end of the school year? What do they do at open house for high schoolers?
Vincent Carter May 17, 2013 at 01:21 am
At $400,000 of Tax Payer money i expected it to be the Contract Negotaitor.
Carlos Garcia May 16, 2013 at 04:43 pm
I imagine the person was a trainer
lovelafayette May 15, 2013 at 10:44 am
This brochure took a lot of work by a small group of people, supported by a cast of 400! We needRead More your help! PRINT AND SHARE AND POST this great flyer/sign. Parks is conducting a stealth campaign for BMX, NO PUBLICITY ALLOWED!! Jennifer Russell is hounding me personally using the CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER as a tool. I have been threatened with fines and fees, citations and misdemeanors, for informing the public about BMX. “Someone” posted our iconic signs, “Your Park with BMX”, on all the park public forum bulletin boards! No photos of the mystery posters exist, Jennifer lied and told code enforcement I admitted to posting THAT sign. I admitted posting signs about the April 8 meeting, but that is not the sign I am charged with! Please help confound the code enforcement officer by printing and posting and distributing this great flyer. Take it to church, youth group, PTA meetings. We could try our own stealth campaign, all wear Giants baseball hats and black hoodies! The rest of the story is at: WWW.NOLAFAYETTEBIKEPARK.COM and www.lafayettebikepark.com (city site) Suzanne Sommer lovelafayette@msn.com
Beau Behan April 23, 2013 at 03:00 pm
Hi Everyone, Thanks for dropping by PATCH. We really appreciate your taking the time. Hard toRead More imagine at times that Tom Cruise has been in the showbiz for at least three decades now.. It is as if it were just yesterday when I first watched "The Outsiders". We will have more film reviews for you all.. Thanks again. Beau
c5 April 23, 2013 at 02:12 pm
He was great in 'Risky Business', still one of my all time favorites. "Ok, which one of you isRead More the U-boat commander?".... :)
KAC April 22, 2013 at 09:56 pm
Tom Cruise? Pass...
LamorindaMan April 17, 2013 at 10:43 am
Will this workshop benefit motorcyclists? Bicycle riding requires way too much work. I'd rather rideRead More a motorcycle and let the engine do all the heavy lifting.
Napoleon Solo April 16, 2013 at 03:44 pm
They think they are doing something for the environment. When one of my kids had to do a schoolRead More project showing they were using recycled materials, I did not have anything reasonable around and had to go to the store, buy a large soda bottle, and pour it down the drain when I got home so there was a "recycled" item for the project. How did that save the environment?
CJ April 16, 2013 at 03:30 pm
Really?- How long is this farce going to be pushed? This has been going on for what seems likeRead More forever. 10 kids (of Envirotreehuggers) and 2- Environazi's will get on their bikes and ride to school and their nearby offices. While the rest of the reasonable people see this for what it is.....ridiculous. This will never be practical and if you want to be so, then do it without all the nonsense. I used to bike 15miles to my job and back, but that was when I was a wacked out Triathlete trying to qualify for Ironman. It is ridiculous as a daily practice for a myriad of reasons. Sustainable Lafaytette? - I sincerely hope this is not an actual public tax money paid position.
lovelafayette May 20, 2013 at 07:12 am
A dog park in Lafayette has been discussed by the Parks Department for years. Carol Singer, ParksRead More Commissioner always expresses interest but it never goes beyond talking. Parks is in the midst of a major review of CIP projects, email Council or Parks and let them know you want a dog park now! Funding is available, we just need to convince parks this is a priority.
TMoraga April 19, 2013 at 12:49 pm
Hey Paula you don't get it. It doesn't matter what happened. #1 School property is not an off leashRead More location. School district insurance doesn't cover such thing. And yes this is a big liability issue. Dogs! Do not belong on CAMPUS! It really is not hard to understand however if one can't grasp why this is a bad idea they probably should not have a dog in their stewardship either.
Paula Capps April 19, 2013 at 11:28 am
The dog group at Stanley has been going to the school for decades. We have always cleaned up afterRead More the dogs and everyone gets along beautifully. It's been a strong sense of community I myself gained from the group of kind and friendly owners. The incident that stemmed this has become distorted. There are other witnesses besides the parents who literally screamed at a very nice mild mannered young man. They cursed at him and treated him like dirt. What kind of an example was that to a child? His dog was not mean, excited yes, but in fact the dog diid NOT even touch the little girl. The girl chased after the dog's rolling ball. The dog came toward her to claim his ball. She freaked out and started screaming. Instead of talking to the little girl and man in instructive and calm ways to show dog and child all was ok the parents made themselves look crazy and the poor man was verbally abused. Dogs need to run and play just like people. I'd like to add it is a fine to throw food wrappers, bottles, cap tops, and unwanted food all over the field, and most anywhere in this lovely Bay Area we all share. l have picked up hands full, two and times each night. Why are parents allowing this? We have a beautiful place to live here please teach children to respect our earth. They'll be around here longer than the adults at this writing.