.
Feedback

Patch Poll: Army vs. Navy, Harvard vs. Yale - Squirrel's vs. Millie's

One of Lamorinda's greatest -- and most subtle -- rivalries is waged every morning over breakfast in Lafayette. Patch thinks it's time to settle this thing.

Patcher and life-long Lafayette resident Aric Martinez provides the fodder for our Patch Poll this Monday: or ?

Sure, some of our roads are a mess and there are important issues to ponder and, hopefully, solve in Lamorinda but as Aric so rightly puts it, this thing needs to get settled once and for all.

"You see... I grew up in Lafayette and I've eaten at Squirrels for 25+ years," Aric writes. "I'm a Squirrel's guy for life, and will only go to Millie's Kitchen if I'm forced, and even then I feel guilty."

Aric has noted the often-argued attributes of Lamorinda's oldest breakfast houses, and thinks it's time the matter get settled. Perhaps not scientifically, but with a by-the-numbers Patch Poll.

"It's sort of Red vs. Blue, Good vs. Evil thing," Aric said. "Millies fans will quickly point out that they have good coffee cake. Squirrels fans will usually grant this but argue that they are not eating in a rickety house, fighting for parking and have way better omelettes. I've heard some heated debates over the years."

Judging from their parking lots and long lines both businesses are doing well and we applaud them for their longevity and commitment to customer service. But we have to know: Are you a Squirrel's Coffee Shop or Millie's Kitchen fan?

As Aric points out, most people are not both.

Katie McKinley November 28, 2011 at 07:58 pm
Squirrel's is the best for several reasons:
1. They will cook whatever you order however you want it. Crispy bacon, extra dark hash browns? No problem. 2. The service is personal and intuitive. Vicky and Shirley are the best of the best! 3. It feels like home. They remember you when you come in and that goes a long way with me. Plus, the food is delicious!
X November 28, 2011 at 09:04 pm
I can't vote until I know if either serves grits. And hash browns only come one way - Waffle House style. Scattered, smothered, covered, chunked, & double diced. Southerners know breakfast food. Y'all make a valiant effort out here, though, bless your hearts. And does either place serve hoe cakes? And with all this recycling talk, how come reusing the bacon grease for other cooking is frowned on?
X November 28, 2011 at 09:08 pm
And if you find yourself in the South & anywhere near a Hardee's it's against the law not to stop in at breakfast time & get a biscuit. So good, and if you're real quiet you can actually hear the plaque forming in your arteries. So, only eat one.
Chris Nicholson November 28, 2011 at 11:40 pm
I know you'll say it is too "corporate" to be legit Southern cooking, but I make a point of visiting Cracker Barrel for a Sunrise Sampler breakfast any time I am south of the Mason-Dixie line. From their website: Two Eggs cooked to order with Grits, Sawmill Gravy and Homemade Buttermilk Biscuits along with real Butter and the best Preserves, Jam n' Apple Butter available. Served with Fried Apples, Hashbrown Casserole and a sampling of Smoked Sausage, Country Ham and Thick-Sliced Bacon.
Eileen November 28, 2011 at 11:46 pm
It's neither of the two, for our family. We started going to Mama's, on Washington Square in SF's North Beach, when my daughter was about one year old, and haven't let the 15-odd mile commute deter us from frequenting Mama's after our move to the 'burbs. The staff love our kids, and vice versa. The food is terrific - for me, it's the Farmer's omelette and coffee cake - and well-priced, especially for The City.
Eileen November 28, 2011 at 11:58 pm
With all due respect, Kenny, New Yorkers know a well-made brunch when they sit down to it. (Eggs benedict, almond croissants, apple pancakes, croque monsieurs, a glass of fresh-squeezed OJ and a strong cup of java - yum!)
And your well-loved "hoe cakes" are well-known to my New England peeps as "johnny cakes" and seem to have their origin among the pop native to the areas around CT/RI/MA. (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonnycake) Regardless of their origin, I agree they're delicious. Years ago, on a college spring break trip south of the Mason-Dixon line, I asked a waitress at a roadside diner what "scrapple" was. Her response still cracks me up: "It's everything bacon and sausage ain't."
Rick Broome November 29, 2011 at 12:06 am
Though I grew up in Lafayette, I moved away in 1997. But from what I remember, Millies always reigned supreme! I know that I did go to Squirrels a few times but it never really left an impression. Now I haven't been back to Lafayette really in the last 14 years, but when I do get the chance to visit the old stomping grounds again I will be sure to take the breakfast challenge to find out once and for all which reigns supreme!!
CJ November 29, 2011 at 01:43 am
Best Breakfast in Bay Area is Betty's Ocean View Diner. But the crowds are horrendous.
EVerything they serve is a level or two above the fare served at all the places mentioned here and I've been to all of them. Try the souffle pancake any flavor you want, it is art.
X November 29, 2011 at 02:16 am
Chris - Cracker Barrel rocks. If you don't get there early on a Sat or Sun morning, you will be waiting in a line outside. CB is always crazy-busy on the weekends.
Eileen - I think the Hawaiians have us all beat. They appreciate the culinary superiority of SPAM!
Kathleen November 29, 2011 at 02:25 am
@Eileen: That interesting...I always thought scrapple was a mid-Atlantic dish, not southern. My mom was from Harrisburg, PA, and she's the only person I ever knew who actually craved scrapple. It's sort of a sausage terrine kind of deal, as I understand it.
dave in moraga November 29, 2011 at 03:07 am
Not to be snippy, but I have been to Betty's. My wife insisted we try Betty's because it was profiled some place. So, we waited in line and had the somewhat expensive souffle pancakes, etc.
Sorry, I want to be left alone with a good cup of black coffee and something sweet. I don't want to be trendy. And the souffle pancake was not art. OK, now I am being snippy.
dave in moraga November 29, 2011 at 03:16 am
Count me in! I am for bacon and against oleo margarine. Butter is making a comeback not seen since Julia Childs nicked herself on SNL with a boning knife.
dave in moraga November 29, 2011 at 03:25 am
I used to play scrapple with my older brother, but to this day I don't believe XZENOW is a word. I thnk he tok advantge of me.
bschoenb November 29, 2011 at 04:55 am
Ranch House Cafe in Moraga
Michael Taylor November 29, 2011 at 11:49 am
...... and Squirrels pulls ahead by a nose!
CB November 29, 2011 at 12:22 pm
I go where the pooch can go. Are either Pooch friendly?
Ann November 29, 2011 at 12:57 pm
Add to Eileen's list of fab NY breakfast food: lox and cream cheese on a REAL bagel. Cannot get those out here :-(
Kathleen is right about scrapple. It's a mid-Atlantic "delicacy" traditionally made from the leftovers of butchering, and can be a mix of meats - beef, pork, etc. I understand that modern scrapple making has a bit more quality control involved, i.e. no offals. In my family we always understood that it's origins were with the Pennsylvania Dutch. Lancaster, PA - cannot get a better breakfast anywhere! Sticking to the local haunts, I vote for Village Inn Cafe in Orinda. Makes the best corned beef hash.
jeff November 29, 2011 at 01:01 pm
village inn in orinda has them both beat by a mile
happy holidays
natalie johns November 29, 2011 at 01:38 pm
Artisan for brunch
Jeff November 29, 2011 at 01:47 pm
I've eaten at both and enjoyed both, but lately we've been breakfasting at La Boulange. Great breakfasts and excellent coffee without the crowds, what's not to like?
Valerie Sloven November 29, 2011 at 03:23 pm
Love La Boulange.
I went to the Village Inn Cafe once and ordered a cobb salad. I asked for the dressing to be mixed in the salad and was told that would be an extra $2 . I never went back again. Dollar pancakes with boysenberry syrup at The Nugget Hotel in Reno.
Catherine Lawler-Troxell November 29, 2011 at 08:25 pm
Tried to go to Rick and Ann's after my stepfather's funeral. there were only 7 of us, but they made us wait an hour and a half, seating about a dozen people ahaead of us. Then they split us up into two tables, when a table came up next to the one we were seated at we asked if we could be moved, so the family could sit together. We were turned down because "it would cause confusion to the server". We left and called Vicky at Squrriel's. She reserved a table for us and was so sympathetic. We should have just gone there in the first place! I will never go anywhere else. We are Squrriels lifers.
Stan Ferber November 29, 2011 at 09:25 pm
Chow, baby!
bryan November 29, 2011 at 09:54 pm
Chow for lunch but not for breakfast. I do like Artisan's brunch.... small and elegant. I see the voting has Millies and Squirrels neck and neck!! I think they're both good.
CJ November 29, 2011 at 10:51 pm
La Boulange? Really? If you are into your eggs being microwaved to death. Their baked goods are pretty good. But any egg dish is to be avoided at all costs!!
CJ November 29, 2011 at 10:53 pm
I would agree with that. Breakfast is really so badly butchered that people raely realize what a good one tastes like anymore.
CJ November 29, 2011 at 10:56 pm
Their potatoes are a step up from any. Poached and scrambled eggs done perfectly, their regular pancakes and waffles have perfect texture and taste. Home made scrapple.Fresh squeezed OJ. Peets across the street if you must.
I could go on. It is a gourmet attention paid to ordinary ingredients normally prepared by hacks.
Sue Haas November 30, 2011 at 08:43 pm
This is a hoot. I heard two Lamomamas arguing the attributes of both restaurants in Trader Js yesterday. They were dead serious and people around them were trying not to laugh. Good fun and looks like a tie to me!!
Tina Chambers December 1, 2011 at 02:38 am
Squirrel - hands down! And as a former Baahhston gal, it's always Hahhhvaaahhhdddd!
Helen Calvert December 5, 2011 at 01:58 am
Village Inn in Orinda is by far the cleanest and the egg dishes come with a great Belgian style waffle. The home made corned beef hash with poached eggs is sublime. Now, if they only had a good coffee cake the place would be perfect.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Lamorinda Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Contra Costa Veterinary Hospital June 7, 2013 at 09:06 am
Woohoo!!! Congratulations to all the adopted pets, families with new pets and the rescues for comingRead More together for such a great cause :)
Laura June 7, 2013 at 10:49 am
Fantastic. I watched a gorgeous orange tabby get selected by a couple when I was buying cat food.Read More Made my day. Way to go CC4C and Pet Food Express.
greg w June 6, 2013 at 04:01 pm
Two of them - one high, one low...guessing burglars or mountain lion
eruc June 6, 2013 at 05:32 pm
KCBS reports missing 23 year old missing man. Vague report but citizens are asked to call police ifRead More seen.
eruc June 6, 2013 at 05:35 pm
More about this...Read More http://www.mercurynews.com/top-stories/ci_23406312/lafayette-police-searching-missing-at-risk-adult
elizabeth June 6, 2013 at 11:44 am
Hopefully, her owner has found her!She was a BEAUTY!
Lana Henderson June 7, 2013 at 12:36 am
On several occasions, I have seen 5-6 chickens pecking their way down their steep driveway on theRead More east side of Saint Mary's Road, very close to the Cattle Chute. I had not read this story earlier. On 6/3 or 6/4, I saw a black hen, alone, out in the road right at the point of the Moraga Commons. It was pecking the pavement on Moraga Road, as cars turning north from Saint Mary's Road were avoiding it. I hope the chicken crossed the road to the trail on the other side. Better yet, I hope it turned around and followed that trail right back to the Cattle Chute and home.